Search

Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors
Search in posts
Search in pages

Deon K. Johnson: As America marks its 250th year, the church has a crucial role to play in accurately telling the nation’s story (long version)

Fifteen-minute read. A shorter version of this interview is also available. 

As an 11-year-old in Barbados, Deon K. Johnson — now the Rt. Rev. Deon K. Johnson — felt drawn to a sacramental life.

“Our parish church was always open, and it was just down the street from my school, so I was that kid after school who would find myself in the church standing behind the altar and acting what I saw on Sunday morning, so it kind of began there,” Johnson said.

A sense of call solidified during the process of confirmation, but Johnson still resisted for years, only to be encouraged forward by a village of advisers.

Since becoming the bishop of the Episcopal Diocese of Missouri during COVID, Johnson’s ministry has come to include a practice of writing daily prayers that he shares through social media. And, as the diocese’s first bishop who is Black, openly gay and an immigrant, he has recently spoken publicly, including with NPR, about a traumatic year for his family. In 2024, his husband, who was born in Mexico but came to the U.S. as a young child, was separated from Johnson and their son and daughter as part of the federal immigration crackdown.

Johnson spoke with Faith & Leadership’s Aleta Payne about his ministry, life and family, as well as the crucial role the church can play as America’s 250th birthday is observed. The following is an edited transcript.

Faith & Leadership: Would you tell us about your call story?

Deon K. Johnson: Confirmation in Barbados takes about a year, because what they really want you to do is to make sure that this is what you’re committing yourself to but [also] to find out what your place in ministry looks like.

The priest at the time insisted that we had to go and be engaged in every single ministry of the church, because he really wanted us to figure out, Where’s your place in this faith community? I was an impetuous child that looked at them and said, “I want your job.” But in many ways, I also resisted answering this call.

It’s biblical in some ways. God calls, we say, “Yeah, yeah, not me,” and God wins.

That’s what’s happened in my life. I immigrated to the United States when I was about 14 and continued to just say, “Hey, church is important to me, but I’ll go get a job out in the world, and at some point I will think about this whole ordination thing.”

I went off to college, and it was there that I finally began to come out to myself. At that time in the late ’90s, early 2000s, we had controversy going on around banning gay marriage and everything, and the church was also continuing to wrestle with all of that.

I said to myself, “Surely this church does not want me.” Yet my priest at the time kept saying to me, “You need to consider going to seminary. I think that God’s calling you to something.” And I kept saying to her, “Thank you, but if God wants me to do this, God will figure it out.”

Her way of letting God figure it out is that she talked to the bishop, and she set up an appointment for me and told me, “Oh, by the way, you’re meeting with the bishop next Wednesday.”

In the back of my mind, I thought, “He’s going to say no, and I’ll just continue with how things are going.”

Strangely enough, I get to that meeting, and he said, “I see a calling.”

I’m like, “What are you talking about?”

F&L: Still trying to talk yourself out of this.

DKJ: I kept trying to talk myself out of it, every step, and at every step someone showed up and said to me, “No, this is what you need to be doing.”

I developed this practice that if people say the same thing to me independently three times, I need to pay closer attention to it. That has served me well throughout my ministry and throughout my life.

When it came time for ordination, I kept going, “OK, God, what do you want? You tell me.” And at every step people have stepped in and said to me, “We really see this in you.” Even when I fight it, they’re able to see it sometimes.

The same thing is true when I became a bishop. There’s a really funny story about allowing my name to go forward to be bishop. I had been in a previous search, and I had said to myself, “Yeah, no, I don’t want to go through that process ever again.”

[Then] one of my friends called me up and said, “Have you seen the profile for the diocese in Missouri?” Another calls me up and says, “Have you looked at Missouri?” I said, “I looked at it. The deadline is too soon. I do not have time to write the essays and fill out the application, because it’s a tedious process. Maybe if they extend the deadline.”

The next week she calls me up and says, “I’m holding you to what you said. Look online. They just extended the deadline until the end of the month.”

I filled out the application, sent all the things in, and this is how it ended. The gift is I’ve had people who at every step have said to me, “You need to respond to this.” It was ironic, coming from a village [in Barbados]; in the village, you think of what’s best for the community rather than what’s just best for me. It really is a community who discerns. It takes a community — it takes a village — to help us actually discern our call, especially when we’re trying, like Jonah, to run away from our call.

F&L: Your family has a history of immigration. You are from Barbados; your husband is from Mexico. You all have gone through a time of trial in this moment of a crackdown on people who have come here as immigrants. Can you talk about your family’s experience?

DKJ: This is a very difficult season no matter where you come from. It is focused on folks coming from the Latin American, Spanish-speaking countries, but it’s affecting everybody.

I am an immigrant, my parents are immigrants, I’m married to an immigrant, and this is our lived reality. With my husband, I have to repeat this often: We were doing everything right. He was brought here as a child, he was approved for DACA, was working, doing all the things, aspiring to that American dream.

We got married, and we filled out all the paperwork. I have advanced degrees, and I can barely get through figuring out the paperwork in English. We’ve done all the paperwork, and everything was filed, and we got a letter saying that we needed to go to Juárez in Mexico for our interview at the U.S. Consulate.

We went to the interview, and the interviewer said to my husband, “You’ve not lived in Mexico for a very long time. I think you need to spend some time there. You may not be going to the United States for a year.”

[Previously] everything had been approved. All of his background checks and everything said, “Here is a model person with children, family, trying to do all the right things.”

The response was, “You’re going to have to stay here for a year.”

We had to quickly figure out going from two incomes to one, [from] having one household to two, taking care of kids, distance. We had to try to figure out how to navigate all of that.

I recognized the privilege that I had in being able to afford to do two households, to be able to get on a plane and all that. A lot of our immigrant siblings don’t have that privilege. There was a lady behind us [at the consulate] from Oklahoma who had driven through a snowstorm to go for her interview, had just had a baby months earlier, and who was told, “You have to stay in Mexico for three years.” Can you imagine having a newborn that you’re not going to see until that baby is three years old? This is how our system is working.

It was a very difficult year for both of us, him being in a place where he had never lived for a significant portion of his life and us on the other side trying to navigate.

At the end of the year, he had to do all of the things [at the consulate] over again. The person who interviewed him said, “Why did you take a year to come for your interview?” He said, “Your colleague told me that I had to stay in the country for a year.” She looked at all of this paperwork and said, “That makes no sense.”

I have to keep emphasizing, I recognize the privilege that I have in being able to do what we did. I think often of folks who don’t have that privilege, whose spouse or son, daughter, brother, sister is in a country where a lot of them have no connection. What’s worse is the family that’s left behind isn’t able to actually go and spend time with those people who have been detained or deported. It was and continues to be something that I’ve been passionate and feel strongly about, just because this isn’t who we should be as a nation.

Photo of a group of priests
A Pride service in June included the Rt. Rev. Gene Robinson, the first openly gay bishop in the Episcopal Church.

F&L: You had shared this story within the diocese as it was happening, but it was not widely known.

DKJ: I shared with the clergy. I had to go visit all the congregations of the diocese, and I still have to live out my vocation. I can’t stop being bishop for a year. I shared it with the clergy and with the instructions, “I ask you to pray for us. Please do not share this publicly.”

I didn’t want to put my husband in jeopardy of any kind during that time, and I also didn’t want to show up [and] the whole congregation to be, “Oh, we’re so sorry,” to kind of reignite the whole thing. It was helpful to me to have the clergy know but not share with everybody else. It was quasi-public, but not quite [public].

F&L: Since it has become more public, what has been the response?

DKJ: I’ve had people who reached out to both of us, sharing similar stories, or saying, “I didn’t quite understand that this is how the system works.”

I had somebody send me a message on social media saying, “If you all had just followed the process, none of this would have happened.” I had to respond by saying, “Do you honestly think that as a bishop I’m going to break the law to try to make this happen? Think about what you’re saying.”

I unfortunately read some of the comments on the NPR story, and some people [said], “They were just trying to game the system.” It’s kind of like I get the narrative that you want this to be, but the reality is very different than what you expect, not only the financial cost to families having to go through green card processes but the emotional toll that it takes.

We are still living with, if he is out driving somewhere, the possibility that he could just be picked up for no other reason than having a broken taillight or a flat tire or something. Who knows? That’s just the reality of living in this season in the life of this nation.

Photo of a group speaking together, two are wearing clerical collars
Johnson first experienced his call to ministry as an 11-year-old in Barbados.

F&L: The way I became aware of your ministry is the daily prayers you write and share on social media. Could you talk about those?

DKJ: I became a bishop in the middle of COVID. I decided, “Let me just put out a prayer in the morning,” and I would pull a hymn or something that was meaningful to me or gave me comfort, just as a way of saying to people, “Look, this is happening, but we can still be deeply grounded.”

Every morning I’d start off finding a prayer from somewhere and just putting it out. Then I said, “This isn’t too bad. Let’s see if I can write a prayer occasionally.” So, I started writing. Occasionally, I would put out one or two among the others, and people were responding to the ones that I wrote more than the ones I was finding and sharing.

It continued to evolve, and I thought, “I’m just going to do this through COVID. I will just continue to write a prayer.” Once COVID is behind us, I would stop and continue doing the things that I was doing.

COVID came to an end, and I stopped for about a month. My inbox got flooded by people, “We didn’t get any prayer. We’re looking forward to your prayer.”

It now has become a part of my daily spiritual practice. A lot of the times the prayer that I’m writing is the prayer that I need to hear or the prayer that I need to be praying.

People will say to me, “Do you sit down and plan out a month’s worth of prayers or something like that?” Nope. Part of my routine has been getting up in the morning to get our son out to school. In the quiet between waking him up and him going to get dressed, I would sit, read the news, and something — like a word, a phrase, an image, something [while] reading the news or staring outside, looking out the window — would spark a prayer. That just continued.

I was on vacation last week, for instance, and we decided to go on a cruise, so I suspect that this week’s set of prayers is going to have a lot of water imagery. The prayer this morning was about a lighthouse because we sailed past a lighthouse. They’re whatever’s happening, sometimes what I’m feeling in response to what’s going on.

I love to write, so it’s a way for me to continue to write, to do something creative, because a lot of my time as a bishop is so challenging. [This is] some time to have a creative outlet. It has become now a foundational part of my own spirituality to write these prayers in the morning. It feels odd when I don’t.

There are seasons when the prayer is literally “Oh God, get me through this day.” And I recognize sometimes that if I’m praying that, it’s giving other people permission to pray the same thing.

Or — we’re seeing some terrible things happen. Being able to name those things in prayer and to live in that space of not knowing how to respond is prayer unto itself. I’m hoping that, because my prayers feel real in many ways, that they give people permission to be just real with God.

Photo of a priest serving communion
Along with his ministry within the diocese, Johnson writes daily prayers that are shared more widely.

F&L: We are in a fraught season as the nation marks 250 years. As you consider past, present, future, the experiences of so many, what would your message be to the church in the most expansive sense?

DKJ: I think the message for the church is that we have to be the keepers of the story. In a season where we’re attempting to erase stories or to tell the stories, as the old people say, “from a slant,” I think the church’s role, especially as we look at 250 years of the American experiment, is to be the keeper of the stories, to tell the parts of the story that are not being told.

We hear of all the things that have happened in the last 250 years, going all the way from, even earlier, the Pilgrims at Plymouth Rock to yesterday. There’s a lot that has happened, and unless we are able to reckon with both the past and the present, it dims the light for the future. I think the church is called into telling the story but also into naming.

In the 1928 Book of Common Prayer for the Episcopal Church, the priest or the layperson, whoever was getting ready to baptize a baby, would lean into the godparents and say, “Name this child.”

It wasn’t just about getting the name; it was about God naming and claiming that child by name, saying, “This person belongs to God.”

In some sense, I think that is part of the role of the church right now; we have to name and claim the stories of those who are being pushed to the side. We have to be the keepers of those stories, of our Native American siblings who were displaced through genocide in our nation. We have to tell the stories of slavery and its atrocity and Reconstruction and Jim Crow and segregation. We have to tell those full stories and not just the cleaned-up versions that make it into textbooks.

I’m a firm believer that those individual stories really do make a difference in getting people to recognize that this isn’t about some event that happened. These are real people’s lives.

I’ve been doing some research on my ancestors, which, for most people of African descent who came to this country or to the Caribbean islands, etc., through enslavement, there is very little [documentation]. But the church records tell stories.

One of the stories that I found is I have a sixth-generation great-grandmother whose name was Eliza Hutchinson, who was enslaved. She went to the church to have her daughter baptized. Mind you, there was no father listed on the certificate; maybe that was the master, but she went to have her daughter baptized.

It’s the vital statistics; you’ve got the name, age, occupation, all the things, but in the margins the priest wrote, “Beautiful singing voice.” I know nothing of Eliza Hutchinson except that she had a beautiful voice to sing, but just that little snippet of my history, knowing that that’s the legacy that she had left fills out the story of what slavery was. That’s why I said that I think that the church is called to name and tell the story, especially in this season.

I think it’s the one place where we can help move this society closer to the dream of God. Unless we tell the truth about our past, we will always be entering into the future without having a full vision.

We have to name and know the trauma that slavery had both on the slaves and the enslaver. Name the trauma that our Native American siblings endured genocide. Call it genocide. When we say, “the displacement or the removal” — let’s name the thing. Let’s stop trying to make this sound as though it was, “Oh, they came and just simply moved a tent community.” There was intentional destruction and death, but until we actually are able as a nation to name those places, to recognize that the good pieces — and the bad pieces — of our history are what make us who we are, we will always be telling and living out only a part of the American dream.

Photo of a group of priests preparing for communion
As the nation marks its 250th birthday, Johnson believes the church has a crucial role to play in truth-telling.

F&L: Do you have any idea what your prayer on the Fourth of July will be?

DKJ: No. That was one I have been thinking about. I try to do a little bit of a reflection on the big High Holy Days. I have some little threads, but I have not woven them together yet. But I think it’s going to center something around the lines of what divides us does not define us.

I’ve been seeing the 250th anniversary all over the place, and I keep hearing about the division. I keep reminding myself, “The things that divide us really don’t define us.” If we look past our division, we are all compassionate. We all want mercy. We all want caring. We want to be seen. We want to know that our lives matter.

I think that those folks who just … Democrats that hate Republicans and Republicans who hate Democrats and independents who hate whoever they want, then we are letting the things that divide us define us, and it doesn’t need to be that way.

Someone said America is a dream, and we get to shape what that dream looks like, if we can get back to the basics of recognizing [that] the things that keep us apart really do not define who we are as a people or as a nation. So, look for that line in one of the prayers.

The last piece that I would add to all of what we’ve talked about today, as someone who came to this country from another culture, [is] a recognition that we all come from someplace else. In God’s creative diversity, we make it work, if we can see past our own shortsightedness.

Touch the pews with your hands, the Rev. Troy K. Venning told the crowd of grassroots activists gathered at Quinn Chapel African Methodist Episcopal Church on a November evening.

“It has been said that the oils of our ancestors are on these pews,” Venning said, quoting the chief architect working on the church restoration. “You never know who was sitting where you’re sitting.”

It’s an illustrious roster: Quinn Chapel has hosted figures such as Ida B. Wells, the Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. and Frederick Douglass, in addition to all the faithful who have been part of its long history. It is the oldest African American congregation in Chicago, dating back to seven people who gathered for prayer in 1844.

photo of a church
Exterior of Quinn Chapel AME Church.

Under the leadership of Venning and his predecessor, the congregation has undertaken a restoration of its historic building and its connection to the neighborhood, revitalizing itself in the process. Quinn Chapel is not only a place to learn about the past but also a place where people can find connection in the present.

“There’s a West African teaching that urges us to reclaim what the past offers so that we can walk into the future with clarity and courage,” Venning said to those gathered for the November meeting about the city of Chicago’s budget.

The meeting was convened by United Working Families, an independent political organization funded by labor unions. Several members of the city council attended, as did Mayor Brandon Johnson. For all of them, UWF is a source of grassroots political support.

“This church is no stranger to the fight for the moral good,” Johnson said, recounting Quinn Chapel’s role as a stop on the Underground Railroad. “Thank you for understanding the collective assignment of liberation.”

Photo of a pastor in front of a sanctuary
The Rev. Sheryll Brown-Venning, first lady and a minister of Quinn Chapel, and the Rev. Troy K. Venning speak to the crowd.

Operation Midway Blitz

In the weeks before the meeting, federal agents were swarming the city and detaining thousands of Chicago-area residents in immigration-enforcement raids as part of Operation Midway Blitz.

Groups formed across the city and suburbs seeking to prevent their neighbors from being taken, actions that recall the role of Quinn Chapel members in resisting the Fugitive Slave Act in the 1850s. The congregation was part of a group of Chicagoans who formed patrols to thwart catchers trying to return people to slavery.

“There was a group of people from this church who started a vigilance society,” Venning said, “to keep people free.”

During the Great Migration in the first half of the 20th century, the church building was a welcoming center for people leaving the segregated South. The late Timuel Black, a historian born in Alabama and raised in Chicago’s Bronzeville neighborhood, said when his family arrived in the city, their first stop after Union Station was Quinn Chapel. They had been told that people at Quinn would tell them where to go next, Venning said.

Venning emphasizes that Quinn Chapel’s story is not only Black Chicago history but U.S. history. Susan B. Anthony spoke at Quinn about giving women the right to vote. A two-seater pew from the sanctuary is at the National Museum of African American History and Culture.

“Quinn Chapel has always been more than a church: It’s been a landing place, a launching place, a liberating place for generations seeking freedom, safety and belonging,” Venning said.

Does your congregation have a history that inspires action in the present?

Vision for restoration

Even with its historical significance, by the late 1990s Quinn Chapel was in danger of closing.

Not only had the congregation shrunk, but the grand building in the South Loop neighborhood near downtown urgently needed repairs. Rain and snow were seeping in and damaging the interior, among other problems.

The Rev. James Moody became pastor in 2002 with a vision for restoration. Under his leadership the congregation grew not only in numbers — from 35 to 400 — but in energy. With concerted effort from his wife, First Lady Corlis Moody, and the restoration team, the congregation began to repair the historic building.

photo of a peeling church ceiling
The tin ceiling in the historic sanctuary is part of a future restoration.

Corlis Moody oversaw grant writing and connected with historic preservation groups. James Moody, who is now a presiding elder for the AME denomination in the Chicago North District, stressed that it was not only the leadership of the church who aided in their success but “specific members with connections and courage.”

Charlotte Flickinger, a church trustee, guided the Moodys through making connections with the state legislature.

“She worked tirelessly and walked those halls and knocked on those legislators’ doors,” James Moody said. Flickinger’s efforts helped Quinn Chapel have $9.4 million earmarked from the state of Illinois for the historic restorations.

Many of the grants received over the years could not go to religious institutions, so Quinn Chapel set up a 501(c)(3) nonprofit specifically for restoration, Moody said.

Who in your congregation has the skills or connections to help further your mission?

A painting on a church ceiling
Plans call for fully restoring this mural at the front of the sanctuary.

Work began with the roof. The phases after that have included two renovations of the fellowship hall, the addition of an accessible ramp and elevator, and creating new offices, meeting rooms and music practice space.

About $12 million has been raised so far. In addition to state funding, they received multiple grants, including through partnerships with the National Trust for Historic Preservation and the National Fund for Sacred Places. Through energy company ComEd and environmental groups, Quinn Chapel had a $650,000 high-efficiency HVAC system installed, cooling its limestone building with air conditioning for the first time in summer 2023.

A future restoration phase will focus on the historic second-floor two-level auditorium, which is also their sanctuary. Its tin ceiling is one of the largest in the nation. There will also be work to fully restore a mural at the front of the sanctuary, where Jesus has dark brown skin and a golden halo, arms outstretched.

The mural and stained glass also reflect the congregation’s history. From what church leaders have learned, the 1904 mural is one of the first North American depictions of Jesus as Black. One of the six angels in the mural was modeled on the way a girl in the congregation listened during worship.

And the Rev. Sheryll Brown-Venning, first lady and a minister of Quinn Chapel, sees a constellation of stars when she looks at the bright spheres dotting the stained-glass windows that have graced the building since it was constructed in 1892. It reminds her of those who fled north following the drinking gourd, also called the Big Dipper.

Hearing the creak of the wood and touching the pews “is majestic to me,” Brown-Venning said. When her husband encouraged her to preach, she felt honored “being able to stand behind the same pulpit that Martin Luther King stood behind.”

Architectural and aesthetic value isn’t the only reason to restore historic church buildings, said Robert Jaeger, president of Partners for Sacred Places, a Philadelphia-based organization. It also has economic and social benefits.

What story does the art in your church building tell?

photo of door handles
Detail from the building, which was built in 1892.

The average urban historic congregation generates $1.7 million annually in value, with 87% benefitting the community beyond its members, according to a 2016 study by Partners for Sacred Spaces collaborating with the University of Pennsylvania. (For rural congregations, the figure was $735,000 annually, a separate study showed.)

That includes employment of staff and drawing visitors who may also patronize local businesses. There is ecological and recreational value in the green space around churches, Jaeger said. Overall, the study looked at more than 40 factors.

Preserving historic sanctuaries also allows them “to do new things for those who are in need,” he said. He believes most congregations want to do that, but repairs can feel like an obstacle to starting programs.

“If you can help invest in that building, invest in accessibility,” as well as in repairs and maintenance, he said, “it benefits outreach.”

Without its restoration efforts, Quinn Chapel could have closed, Jaeger said. “Now it’s a strong congregation that has done a lot of good for that neighborhood.”

Have you assessed your congregation’s community impact? If not, how might you approach such an assessment?

Leadership for the future

When Moody began preparing for a leadership transition, he thought of Venning, who had grown up at Quinn Chapel and was an intern there while a student at Garrett Evangelical Theological Seminary. Venning then served as a pastor of three congregations in Florida.

Moody kept in touch and heard about Venning’s style of pastoral leadership, including at spoken-word poetry events and other venues beyond traditional church settings.

Moody also looked around at Quinn Chapel’s leadership and saw they were mostly people older than 50, he said. Leaders began the transition process with the steward board by inviting more laypeople in their 30s and 40s into leadership roles.

“Those leaders, those baby boomers, actually embraced the idea because they could see Quinn existing years later, decades later,” Moody said.

After a five-year transition process, the congregation asked Venning to come back to be executive pastor in 2019. Venning and Brown-Venning trusted God’s call through a difficult transition for their family, amid a period of deep personal loss and the start of the COVID pandemic. The AME district’s bishop appointed Venning to be senior pastor in 2021. There are still 400 members on the rolls, with 80 to 120 people at Sunday worship.

photo of a group in a sanctuary
Grassroots activists from across the city met in November at Quinn Chapel.

Building on the work the Moodys had done, Venning helped the finance team make necessary updates, including moving to online banking, with checks and balances in place. This was especially important for receiving and managing grant funds they had been awarded.

Venning sees the congregation as being like a train station. People arrive from different places and need a moment to rest before going to their next destination.

“Whether this is your final destination or you’re headed somewhere else, at least you should be able to find the things that you need to keep moving,” Venning said.

Train stations are also places where different people cross paths, bringing everything they’ve carried.

“We’ve always been a place to bring the haves and have-nots together,” Venning said. “I’m a firm believer that when people get to Quinn, they’re here because Quinn needs something that they brought with them, and they need something that we have now.”

The joy of a historic church

Plans involve looking to the past and the future.

The surrounding neighborhood was once the location of a large number of railroad depots and stations. There were also several public-housing developments located nearby. In recent decades, developers have built a lot of high-end housing, along with retail.

In addition to the church, Quinn Chapel owns a lot across the street and five adjacent lots on a nearby major corridor, State Street. In a dense area of the city where there is not much parking, those lots have been generating revenue for the congregation.

Another source of income has come from being a filming location for television and movies. Chicago has a multimillion-dollar TV and film industry, and studios pay restaurants, hospitals and other buildings to film scenes there. Recently, Quinn Chapel’s fellowship hall was used as the setting of Al-Anon meetings in the television series “The Bear.”

The congregation plans to turn property it owns diagonally across from the church building into a mixed-use development with housing, office space and parking. In the church, the first floor will have a bookstore that will sell books that are banned or “someone said you shouldn’t read,” Venning said.

Blocks away from the historic Chess Records studio where some of the greatest blues and R&B artists recorded their music, Quinn Chapel will have a recording studio for artists such as Adrian Dunn, Quinn Chapel’s director of music, worship and arts.

Christopher Wilson, associate music director and administrative assistant, studied audio design and engineering and does audio editing. Now a trustee as well as a staff member, he joined in 2015 as a college student.

Are there unique opportunities for fundraising based on your location?

photo of a map of a museum
Work on the historic building will continue as plans call for continuing to restore the building and also to develop nearby property.

“We’ve stood the test of time and continue to do ministry,” Wilson said. “To grow from a seven-person prayer band into a church that has birthed other congregations — I think that’s pretty remarkable.”

The congregation’s role in the Underground Railroad and the Great Migration will be a highlight of a new museum in the building. Excavating the basement will add 4,500 square feet of additional space. It will have an archives room, another meeting and arts space, and a museum that they hope to open to the public in 2027. It will include artifacts and stories from how the congregation has intersected with broader history.

“For folks who have the joy of being able to pastor in historic spaces, it’s about finding your story and being able to tell it,” Venning said.

The meeting about the city budget in November was one of the many Quinn Chapel hosts. Their main-level event space hosts art installations, movie screenings, educational events and more. Larger events, such as a mayoral forum in the last election, have taken place in the historic auditorium. Some weeks there are events most weeknights and Saturday as well; Venning said that it’s a mistake to focus on Sunday only.

Connecting Quinn Chapel’s legacy and present, Venning recalled the West African teaching of embracing the past’s lessons to move into the future.

“The Sankofa bird looks back while its feet face forward,” Venning told the crowd that evening in November: “We embody what our ancestors practiced: faith in action.”

How might you find your congregation’s story and tell it?

Questions to consider

  • Does your congregation have a history that inspires action in the present?
  • Who in your congregation has the skills or connections to help further your mission?
  • What story does the art in your church building tell?
  • Have you assessed your congregation’s community impact? If not, how might you approach such an assessment?
  • Are there unique opportunities for fundraising based on your location?
  • How might you find your congregation’s story and tell it?

 

As a Christian leader, I have received the grace of learning many things by failure. Perhaps my clearest and most repeated lesson from failure has been about how the Spirit moves differently in various contexts.

Thirty-five years ago, I was a young campus minister, and I recruited about 20 students for an intensive Bible study. Brimming with self-confidence and overflowing with zeal, I led in all the ways I had been taught. I am a white male, and I had learned to lead in a particular style. For example, my communication and conflict styles were polite but quite direct. My previous experiences of learning and leading these studies had been amazing, so I felt like an expert — for about three weeks.

After a good start, I realized my students were not responding like I expected. The group dynamic was slow and tense; it seemed like their commitment was waning. As I discussed this with my wise supervisor, Dana, she didn’t blame the students, and she didn’t rebuke me. Rather, she taught me to ask some new questions.

Dana suggested I meet with each student and ask questions like “What do you experience in my leadership?” and “What might help you feel connected and committed to our group?”

So, with what zeal I had left, I met with each student individually. Those conversations were challenging for me and for the students, in different ways. I had to learn to ask questions and listen carefully without explaining or defending myself. This was surprisingly difficult, and a little embarrassing for the guy who three weeks ago felt like an expert!

My group was diverse, with many students of color. I learned in these conversations that many of them felt it culturally challenging to speak to me about the ways my leadership wasn’t working for them. I learned so much: about communication and leadership and listening, as well as about the cultures and families my students came from. And by the grace of God — and the mercy of my students — all of us recommitted to the study.

From that experience, I began to realize how fundamentally contextual leadership is; what had worked for me as a student wasn’t working for these young people. A transformative Bible study may look very different from context to context. For example, direct forms of communication and addressing conflict were not helpful in my group. Healthy Christian leadership is organic, not formulaic. The ministry of Word and Spirit must be planted in the soil of particular communities, and it grows differently based on where it is planted.

The word in the wilderness

The third chapter of the Gospel of Luke shines light on the role of social context in the movement of the Spirit. Leading up to chapter 3, the reader anticipates something dramatic is going to happen. And sure enough, the word of the Lord comes to the miraculously born prophet John the Baptist, and it comes “in the wilderness.” This was a big deal for the people of God; it had been 400 years since the last prophet.

Luke says that John’s ministry is the fulfillment of Isaiah 40:3-5:

“A voice of one calling in the wilderness, ‘Prepare the way for the Lord, make straight paths for him. Every valley shall be filled in, every mountain and hill made low. The crooked roads shall become straight, the rough ways smooth. And all people will see God’s salvation.’” (Luke 4b-6 NIV)

Isaiah likens the coming movement of God’s Spirit to the most ambitious of public works projects: creating the kind of road that kings and emperors use. Valleys will be filled, mountains cut down and a smooth, straight road constructed. The dimensions of the project are massive!

Yet John’s prophetic ministry, of course, is leveled not at physical mountains and valleys but at the landscape of culture, economics and power. The adjustments to be made, the road to be built, concerns territory of a different order.

In his enactment of Isaiah’s road-building vision, John speaks to Hebrew and Gentile, to rich and poor, and to powerful and weak. He challenges them all to a “baptism of repentance for the forgiveness of sins” (Luke 3:3b). John exhorts children of Abraham not to presume upon their ethnic identity but to humbly seek forgiveness.

He challenges the rich to share with the poor. He challenges tax collectors to live simply and soldiers to reject violence. He does so openly in a crowd where the powerful and marginalized were gathered. This word of the Lord — a baptism of repentance for the forgiveness of sins — arrives in a distinct social landscape and speaks clearly to that context. Word and Spirit always move in ways that both reveal and challenge the social topography.

A map for leaders

I’ve noticed that as a leader I’m often tempted to ignore context and presume that leadership can be formulaic, as if the road to a fulfilled vision will be smooth and predictable. Universal strategies, however, are like the illusion of a mirage in the desert — they appear satisfying but ultimately disappoint.

In order to address this temptation, I have found it helpful to stop and prayerfully reflect on my context, using the following exercise in my book, “Formed to Lead.”

Bring to mind the social context of your leadership role. It could be family, school, organization, professional community or neighborhood. Imagine that context as a landscape with mountains and valleys, and then begin to map the social topography.

Who or what is on the mountaintop in terms of influence, power or voice? Who is in the valley? What does your map look like in terms of resources? What might be the roads or connections between different individuals, groups and levels? To what degree can people or groups change their level in the landscape? What is the nature of religious power or influence in your community?

And finally, where do you fit in this landscape of privilege, power, influence and need?

I find it helpful to actually draw maps of this social topography. When I’m drawing, I often see new dimensions, connections or concerns.

When I practice this, I often learn something about myself by picturing the people, groups and systems around me more clearly. I usually find new insight into God’s movement in my community. I find myself freed from the tempting illusion that I can lead according to a simple formula.

I suggest you try this map exercise. After reflecting on the topography of your context, spend a few minutes in prayer, asking God about distinct ways Word and Spirit might move in your particular landscape. And don’t be surprised if the Spirit gives you new insight about God’s heart and your own calling.

Change isn’t easy. But it can be made easier, says Kara Powell of Fuller Theological Seminary.

Powell and co-authors Jake Mulder and Raymond Chang blend theology, original research with diverse churches, and business literature to offer guidance for congregational leaders in their new book, “Future-Focused Church: Leading Through Change, Engaging the Next Generation, & Building a More Diverse Tomorrow.”

“We are optimists about the future of the church. We’re very aware of some of the really discouraging data about the fatigue of pastors, churches shrinking, young people disengaging,” said Powell, who is executive director of the Fuller Youth Institute, founder of the TENx10 Collaboration and chief of leadership formation at Fuller.

“But fundamentally, we’re optimists because of what we believe about God,” she said. “God is always working and redeeming.”

The book describes four phases — called “zones” — in the change process and includes stories, research findings and reflection questions. The book ends with a chapter called “A Suggested 18-Month Change Journey,” in which they describe a step-by-step process to implement the learnings of the book.

“It includes our research with 1,000 churches, our literature review of really great organizational and leadership and change research, and also Scripture,” Powell said.

Powell spoke with Faith & Leadership’s Sally Hicks about the book and why she is excited about the future of the church. The following is an edited transcript.

Faith & Leadership: How do you hope people use “Future-Focused Church”?

Kara Powell

Kara Powell: We do talk about what needs to change, but really, the bulk of the book is on how to bring about change. It emerged both from struggles that we saw churches navigate as well as what we saw churches take as the best path to experience God’s best future for them.

And we follow a practical theology method in many ways. It’s thoroughly understanding where we are, as well as where God would love to take us, and what is the thoughtful, interdisciplinary, communal process to get from here to there.

We thought, You know what? Churches need help, not just with what needs to change, although we do talk about that in terms of prioritizing youth discipleship, loving our diverse neighbors, loving our diverse community, and then just loving our neighbors in general.

We’ve seen God work in churches, especially through young people. So it’s the bright spots we’ve actually seen in these last 10 years that really inspire us, and we get to tell a lot of those stories in the book.

F&L: Explain a little bit about the definition of the “future-focused church” and the idea of the three checkpoints.

KP: Our core definition of a future-focused church is a group of Jesus followers who seek God’s direction together. It’s about seeking God and knowing where God is calling us. This isn’t something we create on our own. We seek God.

It’s also something that no individual leader does. It’s “followers” — plural — not a single leader who feels they need to come up with the perfect vision for the future.

The second half of the definition is the three checkpoints that we think are essential for churches in the future: relationally discipling young people, modeling kingdom diversity and tangibly loving our neighbors.

When we look at Scripture, when we look at churches and when we look at the world today, those seemed like three priorities that are important across the board.

Now, our future-focused process can be used with any change. If a church wants to become more prayerful, great, you can use the process. If a church wants to be more involved in local or global outreach, wonderful, you can use the process. But much of what we describe relates to how our process helps bring about those three changes.

F&L: How are they related to each other?

KP: This generation is the most diverse generation we’ve ever had in the U.S. In 2020, we crossed a line that now half of those under 18 are young people of color. So when we’re talking about young people, we’re talking about diversity. And what young people desperately want to give and receive is the chance to love their neighbors.

F&L: You merge research, business literature, Scripture and theology in a blend that seems like it would help folks on multiple levels. What was your strategy?

KP: That’s exactly what we wanted to do. The Fuller Youth Institute, which is where the book emerged, was very committed to an interdisciplinary process grounded in Scripture that constantly moves from the needs of leaders and families to grounded solutions and then back to the need. So this iterative process, which is just how we think, we really tried to capture in the book.

Readers have found all the stories of churches really helpful, especially that some of the churches were close to closing. Most of our stories are from smaller churches, and so readers are appreciating that. They feel like they can find their community in the pages of the book instead of it just being a single narrative of one church.

F&L: One strong emphasis is diversity. This is a time when in certain quarters diversity is not being lifted up. Why is it so important, in your view?

KP: It is interesting — in interviews, some people avoid the topic of diversity altogether and others really want to hear more. Admittedly, it feels different talking and writing about diversity than it did when we submitted the manuscript a year ago.

But our thinking hasn’t changed, because it’s honestly grounded in Scripture and grounded in what we believe about God creating all people in God’s image.

Our Fuller president, David Goatley, has really given us some helpful imagery, which made it into the book, about the vibrant variety that God intends. It’s about reflecting who you’re trying to serve.

So that’s what we say to churches, “First off, we think Scripture invites us to love all people. And secondly, we would love for you to reflect the diversity of who you’re trying to serve or the diversity of your community.”

The invitation is to those churches and ministries where we’re in communities and we’re trying to serve folks, [but] our ministry is not reflecting that full diversity. I think that’s the gap that we want to help leaders bridge.

F&L: In your process, you talk about diversity in other ways as well. One suggestion is to identify the people who might disagree with you and include them in the change process, which might seem a little surprising.

KP: I’ll highlight two areas where we really emphasize diversity. One is in the transformation team, which we define as a group of five to 12 people dedicated to making the change. And what we found works in churches is when those teams reflect who you’re trying to serve.

In the case of young people — we focus a lot on young people in the book — we recommend you involve young people in that transformation team. Then think about the other areas of the church where we want young people to connect.

We tell a story of a church with a transformation team that had two young people on it, but it [also] had somebody from women’s ministry and somebody from worship ministry and somebody from tech ministry, so that they could think about how young people could thread their way throughout the fabric of the church. I think that’s beautiful.

You’ve highlighted a second type of diversity that we encourage, which is diverse viewpoints. It’s so much easier as a leader to spend time with people who agree with us. But the flip side is, first, we often learn from those who disagree with us. Usually people who disagree with us have important insights that we need to factor into our change process.

The second reason to keep building relationships — even with those who disagree with us — is our change principle. People support what they create. The more we can involve people [so that they are] being heard and feeling like they are helping shape the change, the more they’ll tend to support it.

In general, people want to be listened to more than lectured to, and so we recommend that for leaders across the board.

F&L: The inclusion of young people isn’t just the goal, it’s the process, right? Why do change leaders need to engage young people?

KP: First, I try to start always with theology, and there’s so many examples in Scripture of how important it is to bring the generations together. That’s what the early church was, all generations coming together. I would say it’s theologically grounded.

Second, it certainly is vocationally grounded for me. I feel a calling to young people. And even as my roles keep expanding at Fuller, I’m trying to spend at least 50% of my time on young people because that is the tree trunk of my calling. I have other branches, but young people are the tree trunk.

But the third level that comes to mind for me is that if we don’t engage young people, our churches are going to die. There’s just an inescapable reality to that. It’s not just placating young people and getting them to come join what we’ve always done. It’s handing the keys to young people and co-creating with them.

That’s part of what’s really exciting about this generation, specifically Gen Z and Gen Alpha; they want to co-create. They don’t want to be spectators; they want to be participants. They’re created in God’s image with amazing gifts and have expertise that we need.

F&L: Listening is often recommended for various reasons, but you say that one of the reasons you listen to people is to understand their “mental model.” What do you mean?

KP: Our colleague Scott Cormode has helped us understand mental models.

We have limitless mental models. We have a mental model of what a car is: When you and I think of a car, we have a picture in our mind. When you see something that’s markedly different from the cars you’re used to, it’s startling. You usually reject it.

It’s only as we spend time with people that we understand, What is it they think church should be? What is it that they think worship should be? What is it that they think youth discipleship should be?

As we spend time with them, we understand, Oh, they think of worship as two hymns and then a sermon, and then a hymn and response. If we’re going to change that, we need to understand where they’re starting from and then offer them different mental models.

Maybe instead of two hymns and a sermon and then a hymn and response, we might integrate five minutes of discussion time where people turn to each other in their pews or seats. Because we want a mental model where we’re not just listening but we’re building community with each other, not just engaging with God but also engaging overtly with each other. Listening is so key for mental models.

Another reason listening is so important is because of the lack of trust people feel toward institutions. If you look at data in the U.S., trust in institutions is declining; trust in religious institutions is declining. Young people’s trust is especially declining.

The research on trust shows we don’t rebuild trust through a grand heroic gesture. We rebuild it through everyday acts of integrity, of listening, of caring, of following up when somebody shares a need with us. I think listening is how we’re going to rebuild trust with people who are understandably a little skeptical of the church based on what they see these days.

F&L: Is there anything I didn’t ask that you’d like to add?

KP: A leader can read this article on their own, but they can’t bring about change on their own. Even if it’s two other people who can be part of your transformation team, whatever size church you are at, can you please involve a few other people in your change? Because we’re meant to lead in community, and change happens more effectively in community.

In general, people want to be listened to more than lectured to, and so we recommend that for leaders across the board.